Talk to an engineer

Home / Field notes / Speed shown on a stopped drive

When SCADA shows speed on a stopped drive

A dead feedback signal reads zero. A stopped drive that reads 53 Hz is telling you something different, and it decides whether you need parts at all.

Talk to an engineer

The symptom

On a plant monitoring system we surveyed, several drives showed STOP with a plausible running speed next to it: 45.6 Hz on one, 53.1 Hz on another. A different drive showed exactly the same 53.1 Hz. Meanwhile two drives that were running showed 0.0 Hz.

The obvious reading is "the feedback is missing, fit new I/O modules". The numbers say otherwise.

Why it is not a dead signal

A broken 4-20 mA loop reads zero or under-range. It never holds a believable 53.1. And two separate drives do not fail to the identical value by coincidence. Both faces of the problem, stopped-with-speed and running-with-zero, fit one fault: the value stopped updating, or it is coming from the wrong source.

Things that freeze or mis-source a speed value:

  • A lost network connection, where the controller keeps the last data it received.
  • Logic that only moves the speed value while the run bit is on.
  • A faceplate or tag pointing at the wrong drive. On a zero-based array, [3] is the fourth drive, not the third.
  • The drive's analog output set to a speed reference instead of the actual output frequency. A reference keeps its value while the drive is stopped, which is exactly what "STOP, 53.1 Hz" looks like.

Hardwired does not mean the path is proven

On that plant every drive was hardwired to the monitoring system, and remote start and stop worked. That only proves the digital and relay side. The speed comes back on a different path: the analog output on the drive's I/O option module, through its wiring, into an analog input and its scaling.

Three readings at the same moment

Take all three together, with the drive running and then stopped:

  1. The drive keypad's Output Frequency.
  2. The mA at the analog output terminal on the drive's I/O module.
  3. The value on the SCADA screen.
What you findWhat it means
Terminal mA wrong, AO source set to output frequencyThe I/O module or its output is faulty. This is the only case where a new module fixes it.
AO source set to a reference or commanded speedA parameter change, not a part.
Terminal mA right, SCADA wrongWiring, the analog input channel, or the scaling in SCADA.

Where to look on a PowerFlex 750

On a 22-Series I/O module the analog output source is P75 Anlg Out0 Sel, which defaults to motor velocity feedback. P80 and P81 set the output's high and low, and the output tops out at 20 mA. That gives a quick test: if SCADA shows a value above what 20 mA represents on its scale, for example 53.1 on a 0 to 50 Hz span, that value cannot be coming from the drive's analog output.

On a PowerFlex 755T the host parameters live on port 10, and the analog output source is 10:1044 Motor Vel Fb.

Why we check before we quote

New I/O modules are easy to price and easy to fit. If the real cause is a parameter, a tag address or a scaling, they fix nothing and the screen still shows 53.1 Hz the week after. A meter and the keypad decide whether there is anything to buy.

Questions engineers ask

Why does SCADA show a speed when the VFD is stopped?

Usually because the value is frozen or comes from the wrong source, not because the signal is dead. A dead 4-20 mA loop reads zero. Check whether the drive's analog output is set to a speed reference rather than output frequency, and whether the SCADA tag points at the right drive.

How do I test a VFD speed feedback signal?

Compare three readings at the same moment: the keypad's output frequency, the mA at the drive's analog output terminal, and the SCADA value. Where they stop agreeing is where the fault is.

Which parameter sets the analog output on a PowerFlex 750 I/O module?

P75 Anlg Out0 Sel on the 22-Series I/O module, with P80 and P81 setting the output range up to 20 mA. On a PowerFlex 755T the velocity feedback source is 10:1044 Motor Vel Fb.

Where we do this.

More field notes.

Start with the plant, not the proposal.

Send a photo of the panel, the drive or the problem. An engineer answers.

WhatsApp an engineerdean@tgecorporation.com